Goodwins music video theory
Goodwin believed that music videos obtain seven elements including:
1. Music videos demonstrate genre characteristics i.e within the music video for the song their are elements which are suited to the artists chosen genre. This allows the audience to be comfortable in the fact that they're watching the right thing for them as it is from a genre they like as well as allowing the artist to follow the codes and conventions of the genre to ensure that they shall be pleasing their audience and keeping to what they expect.
2. There is a relationship between the lyrics and visuals, meaning that what is being shown in the video is relatable and fits to the lyrics within the song.
3. There is a relationship between music and visuals so either illustrative, amplifying, contradicting, the visuals match the music beat, through the micro elements.
4. The demands of the record label will include the need for lots of close ups of the artist and the artist could develop motifs that recur across their work. So a visual style which the artist is presenting so to help build a relationship with their audience.
5. There is frequently reference to notion of looking i.e screens within screens or telescopes etc. As well as there being particularly voyeuristic treatment of the female body. This means that the audience is viewing he artist in a voyeuristic way, one which the artist themselves is unaware of.
6. There is often inter-textual references this would include examples such as TV shows, films, other music videos as well as various other forms of mass media etc.
7. Finally a music video includes the concept of whether the video is primarily performance based, concept based or narrative based as well as how elements of each is used within it.
To demonstrate how this theory works I shall be applying it to music video by artist Marina and The Diamonds 'Oh no'.
Marina and The Diamonds is known to fit to more than one genre throughout her musical work including alternative/Indie pop. The artist is recognised for being someone who likes to base her work around things which she feels are important and deserve addressing.Which in itself has connotations of the indie genre as it is often thought to be more in depth than other genres, a lot further away from the mainstream type of music, often it is thought to be music aimed more towards people who really want to focus on the music and look for any messages rather than just listen to the beat. This is also highlighted throughout the video, fitting to Goodwin's theory indicating that music videos demonstrate genre characteristics as characteristics for the pop indie genre are displayed. One way in which this was done was through the references to pop art which begin from the very start of the video. This reassures the audience that they are watching a video that they shall like and feel comfortable with as the artist makes sure to show genre characteristics which makes sure that she is doing her job of fitting to the genre the audience are expecting. As well as being able to qualify to the audience that she is mocking the pop culture of modern society within her lyrics which is important as it means that her fans are able to fully understand Marinas message which can often lead to the audience feeling as though they are able to relate to her more and helping them to follow the music with more ease. After all if people are unaware of what a song really means they might not want to sing it in public very confidently etc if someone was to ask them or they don't know and it could turn out that other people do and they're not singing about something they would't feel comfortable talking about etc. A good example of this would be artist Lady Gaga for instance her lyrics from her hit 'love game' "I wanna take a ride on your disco stick". Someone could be singing the lyrics blissfully unaware of the crude intentions behind the lyrics which they feel may in turn send out a negative message about themselves.

Another element filling Goodwin's theory displayed within 'Oh no''s music video is the concept that there must be a relationship between the lyrics and what is being shown within the video. For instance the line which Marina lip syncs to as a part of her performance element to the music video 'TV taught me how to feel how real life has no appeal' occurs as Marina is dancing in front of different televisions and is then holding one with her head inside as she dances with it. This shows a more fun side to the artist which can be beneficial as it adds to her likely ability factor meaning that people shall be more interested in her music as they are drawn to her as a person. This is beneficial to Marina target audience of thirteen to eighteen years old the video is simple enough to connect with the audience on a fairly simple level but also provides enough underlaying meanings etc that it can aim towards older teens on a more intelligent level aided via it's various references and further messages/meanings etc. For Marina building a relationship with her target audience is important as they are at an age where they are going to be having music forced on them all the time as it is constantly being played in the places you would expect them to be: shopping centres, sixth form common room, parties etc this is also dudded with the stereotype that this is the generation that are more into their music as they have grown with the change in music as well as the technological elements which have helped cave it. Hence providing more meaning behind her lyrics, music videos etc helps Marina to stand out against competing artists and helps her target audience to feel an even stronger connection with her. In doing so Marina is ensuring that fans will remember her and be more likely to want to buy her music as they like her as a person and her happy to support her.
The visuals (i.e what is shown within the music video) also shares a relationship with the music playing along with it. For instance the artist is seen wearing boxing gloves punching the air to the beat. This helps viewers to flow to the beat with more ease therefore enjoying the song more and feeling more comfortable as well as becoming a part of Marina choreography showing off more of her talents. Marina usage of her micro element fits well to the beat as it almost sounds as though something is being punched as it has that kind of beat. This also helps the audience to remember this part of the song and helps it flow more. One way this is works is through the fact that the audience shall remember this part of the choreography for the music video with this part of the beat and therefore it helps with the flow and enables the to dance or sing along wit more ease are they are more comfortable in their knowledge of the song. However this is fairly unconventional towards the genre of indie pop as often particularly in indie music videos follow more of a narrative than the artist simply performing in front of them hence if a certain item was mentioned in the lyrics of a song it would be difficult for it to also be at the scene on hand ready to be brought in in time for it to match up with the lyrics. However being unconventional towards the genre may also be beneficial towards artists including artists such as Marina and the Diamonds who is recognised for being rather different and quirky as it highlights that although she can suit to certain genres she can still do so whilst being herself and not feeling the need to suit to everyone else's standards. This helps follow the tone she had already set and created to share with her target audience hence building upon the already existing relationship. It also benefits Marina as it demonstrates how she is able to experiment with many different elements of the music industry and is talented throughout a wide range of it. This creates further respect for the artist as fans view her as being someone who is truly talented on a range of different levels making the audience more interested in her as they can see that she is passionate, hard working and able to create her music for herself without allowing restrictions to weigh either her or her music down. This added respect leads to the audience likely the artist more and therefore in turn becoming more likely to look out for or buy her music.
Marina also forefills Goodwin's theory by displaying close ups which according to Goodwin shall be demanded for via the record label. This is demanded for as it helps the artist to build a relationship of sorts with the audience. Which is even more beneficial to the artist as her target audience being of that impersoniable and vulnerable age really notice/ pick up on elements such as this. Seeing her face frequently urges the audience to feel a subconscious bond of trust between themselves and the artist as she isn't shying away from the camera of hiding parts of herself, she is displaying herself to them in full which allows the audience to feel as though they are viewing the real her. It also helps to promote the artist, often people claim that they find it hard to remember who people are simply off of names a good example of this would be when people are reading novels etc and they can't create a picture for a certain characters and the narrative becomes a bit confusing and therefore doesn't obtain quite the experience the reader was aiming for. Once people are able to put a face to a name they often find that they are able to relate more to this person as they have better image for them which helps them to remember who they are. When people start to know or recognise an artist they begin to receive a lot more publicity which is good for the artist as this means more magazine deals etc landing themselves further jobs and promotions. Displaying many close ups throughout the music video not only ensure that the audience are well aware of who the artist is but it also helps them to remember as well as demonstrating her from a range of different angles with multiple different looks helping the audience to see more of her making her more recognisable in the future.
Record labels usually demand close ups particularly with female artists in a bid to show an attractive side to the artist. As often it is thought that throughout the media a lot of people reach the heights of fame due to their good looks as people see this side to them shall feel one of two things if this theory is working correctly. This will either look at the artist and feel that they look up to them due to their appearance as they like their style and feel that they want to look like them, or this is usually aimed towards the male segment of the audience, they are made to feel desire for the artist which leads them to obtain further interest in both her and her work. Which also links to another concept of Goodwin's theory that the way in which the audience look upon female artist in music videos is through voyeuristic treatment of the female body. Through showing an attractive side to female artists such as Marina the record label may be attempting to reach help Marina reach out onto other platforms of the media which would not only reflect well on the company but they may also receive further profits from this. Other areas of the media Marina could branch out onto due to the general audience finding her attractive include magazine deals which are based primarily around the photo shoot side to the interview, as well as more interviews on TV talk shows where she is invited to the show to discuss other things presides just her music improving how well known they are. However this does also enable the artist to get a better look at the artist which can make them feel as though the artist is providing them with more of themselves and isn't hiding away which can provide connotations that the artist isn't hiding anything from the audience and is being themselves both on and off stage.
Goodwin's theory also follows that within music videos there is frequently reference to the notion of looking. Although this is usually hinted at in a rather subtle manner, Marina literally has her head inside a screen yet she is looking outside of the screen onto the real world, which can be viewed as reference to the belief that we should focus more on whats really happening around us rather than behind various different screens including TV's themselves as well as tablet and phone screens etc. However this also fits to Marina's lyrics as well as the message she is trying to bring across to her audience that as a society we are allowing parts of the media to control our lives. This enables the artist to highlight exactly what she is referring to to her audience in an almost comical manner. Although the concept of providing such a message like this is very indie as the genre is known for providing much deeper meanings behind their lyrics etc the concept of actually physically showing or holding things to outright explain or represent what the artist is talking about is actually rather unconventional towards the indie genre. As often artist of the indie genre assume that their audience are clever enough and able enough to work out or understand what it is they are trying to bring across with their music and if not then they hope that they will go away and find out on their own. However it is a very pop thing to do as often the pop audience aren't thought to want to listen to music which is going to dampen their mood a little bit or make them consider things more deeply but simply work as music to brighten the mood or something to dance to. Hence Marina is display a strong combination of both genres highlighting how well she is able to mix them together again showing off her wide range of talents allowing the audience the comfort in the knowledge that the artist is able to provide for them a good basis for a well thought out, well varied view for the music industry. This makes the audience feel although listening to Marina shall provide them with a better insight hence feeling as though they are gaining something from buying her music rather than just seeing it as a simple exchange when Marina the face of the exchange gets to earn money.
Said theory also believed that a music video often contains inter-textual references to other elements of the media including topics such as TV/film, even other music videos, video games etc. Although Marina doesn't obviously references towards particularly TV programs or films etc she continues to make references to different media forms as a whole through her video. From the very beginning the pop culture references begin with references towards comic books and pop art, after which at 0:12 the audience is shown Marina holding a made up newspaper after which she moves onto a made up magazine to which she pulls an over exaggerated face mocking the tabloids and to an extent some of the reactions towards them. These references occur from the off set and throughout and are often paired with money highlighting how Marina feels that society has become obsessed with superficial and material things which don't really matter. Again these references help Marina to qualify what it is she is saying to her audience and provide them with a more proficient understanding. It is good for the artist to show this less serious side to the audience and it allows them a wider insight to her as a person and stops her from becoming this artist with a high power with all her songs with deeper meanings and messages etc instead this allows her to create more of a personality which aids her in becoming more relatable. This is rather typical of the pop genre as artists of the genre are thought to be well rounded entertainers who are always ready and able to perform hence if Marina was to portray herself as simply being this indie type character with a conscious mind set she wouldn't be suiting the pop genre and she certainly wouldn't appear to be someone who is able to perform on demand.
Finally the theory also follows that the query of whether the music video is based primarily on performance, narrative, or concept based as well as how said elements of each are used within the music video. Throughout the entirety of the video Marina is seen lip syncing to her lyrics, if not then she is playing along to a form of concept for instance when reading she was playing up to the idea of how people react to the tabloids, she is often seen performing dance routines, which are put in to fit the performance element clearly and are not meant to be appear as though they sort of just naturally happened. As the dance moves are so precisest, as well as the fact that Marina is clearly very good at dancing and all the extra dancers she has dancing around her in a well structured circle all of which have been clearly dressed for a reason aiding to put of both the performance and the concept of the music video. Marina is wearing a very different dress to the rest of these women in a loose fitting dress, where as all of the other dancers are wearing tight, revealing latex dresses. This highlights the concept that Marina feels society is falling to it's on pressures and that we are thinking more superficially as all of these women are clearly trying to attract positive attention for their bodies and wanted to be adored whereas Marina represents herself in the video as wanting to change thing hence she isn't wearing this form of clothing yet what she is wearing is still a pretty dress. Without having to outright direct it in her lyrics Marina is telling her audience which is primarily female based that they women don't need to expose themselves to receive male attention and that they also shouldn't feel the need to do so just to fit in as everyone else is doing. This is also represented as although Marina is clearly shown as the outsider in the dancing group she is the one in the middle and the one who the audience pays the most attention to. However there isn't a narrative as such behind the music video as it doesn't really flow in terms of one, the video just goes from one scene to another and then back to previous ones as the audience watches Marina perform and is shown connotations towards the concept behind both her song and her music video. Hence the video mainly performance and concept based.
The performance element to the music video is follows the codes and conventions of the pop genre as it displays the artist as being a well rounded performer which pop stars are expected to be as they are known for putting on big stage performances such as girl bands like girls aloud even resorting to lip syncing instead of actually singing so that artists are able to focus more on the performance and less on the actual quality of singing as the audience are they expecting more of a show than anything. Hence Marina is often displayed engaging in dance routines either on her own or with a group of girls throughout the music video so to conform to the genre and keep the audience entrained.
This performance elements is also followed up through the artists lip syncing throughout the music video which connotes to the artist that is also able to sing as well as the song playing again illustrating her to be a well rounded performer who is worthy of her pop statues.
Goodwin's theory can be set to a music video in a variety of different ways as well as being beneficial towards one. However although it is true for a lot of music videos there will be music videos which don't follow the set structure of Goodwin's theory completely. For example there are music videos which don't include references towards other elements of the media etc. That doesn't mean that Goodwin's theory isn't helpful and quite often accurate but sometimes there is no need for certain elements within stories as they don't fit to the lyrics or narrative etc.
Whilst analysing the music video I was able to pick up inspiration for my own music video for instance I have decided that I will include many close ups of the artist like Marina and the Diamonds, showcasing a range of different angles, expressions, costumes and make up styles throughout these close ups so to help the audience gain a better image of the artist as well as helping them to see different sides to the artist helping them to build a stronger relationship and seeing them as more of a person making more relatable encouraging the audience to want to follow the artists work more so.
I have also taken care looking over the elements of mise en scene used throughout the music video and decided that I like the idea of different costume changes as it helps the audience to set out different parts of the music video with each other as well as setting the scene. Plus it keeps the music video a little bit more fun and interesting whilst allowing the audience to see more of the artist providing them with a better understanding of the artist.
One of Goodwins theory points which the artist has followed within her music video which I plan to adopt within my own is the concept of displaying voyeuristic treatment of women and the female body e.g allowing and encouraging the audience to view the artist in a voyeuristic manner of which the artist playing their 'character' within the video doesn't realise. I plan to do this as it is a good way to which the audience build a relationship with the artist as they are seeing more of them in a more physically appealing way which shall both help them to remember them as the artist has provided more of an experience for them but it also courses the audience to remember the artist further as they feel more of a connect with them due to tho reaction the artist provoked within them. This method is also something which I want to suit to my music video as having analysed Winehouse's music videos I have noted that it is a technique of which she has frequently used herself helping the artist to display her soul side to the audience highlight important parts of her mise en scene relating to the genre such as her make up. Whilst also suggesting to the audience that she craves a deeper bond with them as she doesn't shy away from the camera and keeps her face close to the screen enabling the audience to feel as though they really know what the artist looks like and would be able to recognise them instantly if they were to see them in the real world.